Discussion about this post

User's avatar
HKJANE's avatar

Jack is correct.

The piece identifies something that most political analysis misses entirely: the crisis is not simply what is being done, but what sustained exposure to it does to the population being governed. Jack is correct. Historians have a name for the condition he is describing — the exhaustion of civic agency — and it has appeared before, in Weimar, in late Republican Rome, in every society where the velocity of institutional breakdown outpaced the population’s capacity to orient itself. What Jack calls cognitive overload, Hannah Arendt called the precondition for totalitarianism: not the dramatic seizure of power, but the prior exhaustion of the public’s will to resist it. The people who adapted best in those periods shared one trait Jack names precisely — they refused to let the baseline shift. They held the earlier reality in memory and kept measuring against it. Note which regimes understood this first: the ones that have historically sought to accelerate confusion did so because an exhausted population is a manageable population.

Note also what normalization does. The rapid cycling of shock — one crisis replacing another before the last has been processed — is not random. It is a mechanism. Each wave of instability that passes without sustained response teaches the nervous system that instability is simply the weather. It is not the weather. It is a condition being actively produced. The moment a population begins treating constitutional crisis, institutional corruption, and democratic erosion as background noise — as the ordinary texture of daily life — the work of dismantling democracy is largely already done. No tanks required. Only exhaustion, and the slow accommodation of the unacceptable.

The body is not separate from that calculation. Sleep, physical movement, deliberate disconnection from algorithmic stimulation — these are not self-care. They are the maintenance of the instrument of resistance. A nervous system in permanent activation cannot think historically. It can only react. And systems that thrive on reaction know this. The act of protecting your own clarity — your sleep, your body, your information boundaries — is therefore not retreat. It is the precondition for everything else. That act of measurement, sustained deliberately against the pressure to normalize, is not comfort. It is resistance. The people reading this piece should understand that clearly.

#HOLDFAST

Virginia Cutler's avatar

Two things help me stay oriented-

1. understanding what is happening, by reading good sources including books on authoritarianism, and history

(this knowledge makes it impossible to be gaslit, which is the most confusing feeling of all)

2. Finding and taking action with other people who have scaled the learning curve, and no longer doubt the truth of what is happening

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?